Mermaids (1990)

You look at the poster for this movie and think... I hope this isn't a movie about a woman who thinks she's a mermaid and her children who have to deal with it. But luckily for all of us, it's just a costume she wears to a strange Christmasy/New Year's Eve/Costume party.

Mermaids is instead the story of Mrs. Flax (Cher) who basically does whatever she wants and when it backfires on her, she just picks up her family and moves somewhere else. She doesn't really seem to care how this affects her two children - teenaged Charlotte (Winona Ryder), who wants to become a nun despite being Jewish, and Kate (Christina Ricci in her first film role), a grade schooler who'd like to break the world record for not breathing underwater. At the beginning of the film, they're on their 18th move and Charlotte is having trouble coping.

If you've never seen Cher in film before you may be surprised to find out she's a decent actress. Christina Ricci isn't given any terribly difficult material but she does just fine with what she has - not distracting from any of the adults with the "acting" to which some child actors are prone. It's Winona Ryder who really makes this movie though. Her narration interspersed with in the moment internal monologuing helps you get attached to her quickly. Emotions she goes through in voiceover are also readily apparent in her expressions on the screen. Ryder's maturity makes her ideal for this role.

As for other aspects of the film... well, it takes place in the 1960s but looks more so like a fictional place. You almost expect a saloon to be next door to their friend Lou's shoe store. All the buildings are pale and seashore colored, except for the nunnery next door that looks like a dark and overly foreboding tower in the weeds. Just keep your eyes on the characters and you'll be in for an interesting ride.

Rating: 3/5
Recommended for: Winona Ryder fans.

Extended Review: There seems to be a case of "oh-shoot-we-have-to-end-this-movie" going on here. Mrs. Flax and Charlotte have said what they need to say. They've come to some sort of a deal that holds no promise of a long term solution. I know... let's dance! It looks like they're having fun even though it's logically way too soon for that if things are really going to change in that household. The only worse choice of an ending that could have been made is a freeze frame of the three girls in a group hug.